15.9 C
Los Angeles
Saturday, May 30, 2020

Malabu Oil Deal: Nigerian government’s $1bn lawsuit against Shell and Eni struck out by UK court

Must read

Brands pay millions for my body – Actress Biodun Okeowo

Nollywood actress, Biodun Okeowo, has revealed that she is being paid millions for her body structure after an internet troll body-shamed her on...

Six Nigerian Air Force personnel attached to ex-CDS, Alex Badeh, sent to jail

Six Nigerian Air Force personnel who were aides to Late Air Chief Marshal Alex Badeh, have been sent to jail by a Special Court-Martial...

387 new cases of COVID-19 recorded in Nigeria; 254 in Lagos alone as total number hits 9302

387 new cases of COVID-19 were recorded in Nigeria, on Friday, May 29, 2020.  According to the Nigeria Centre for...

Illegal abortions responsible for mysterious deaths in Azare –Bauchi government reveals result of findings

An investigation carried out by the Bauchi State Primary Healthcare Development Agency has revealed that illegal abortion by unqualified medical practitioners is...

The Nigerian government’s $1 billion lawsuit against oil giants; Royal Dutch Shell and Eni, has been dismissed by a UK court on grounds of lacking the jurisdiction to hear the case centered on the Malabu oil deal of 2011.

British Judge, Christopher Butcher who gave the ruling in a virtual hearing on Friday May 22, said the cased could not go ahead in England, and also denied the Nigerian government the permission to appeal against the judgment. 

Barnaby Pace, a journalist and oil campaigner who monitored the judgement which has set back the long standing trial, tweeted; 

Justice Butcher of the English Commercial Court should rule this morning whether Nigeria’s $1bn lawsuit against Shell and Eni over alleged bribery in the massive OPL 245 deal will go ahead in the UK or struck out as being duplicative of the ongoing proceedings in Italy.

The hearing’s happening online so its an old photo outside the Royal Courts of Justice! The listing says the hearing will be for “Consequentials /Further Arguments” so there will likely also be arguments over costs as well as the handing down of a judgement.

Justice Butcher rules that the English court does not have jurisdiction. More details to follow once we get the written ruling. This of course doesn’t affect the ongoing Italian proceedings where Nigeria has a separate legal claim. Eni is now making argument for costs against the Federal Republic of Nigeria.

FRN has agreed with Shell that they will pay 60% of Shell’s costs. Justice Butcher’s written ruling finds the English case and the Italian proceedings have the same parties, same essential facts (or cause of action), and considered broadly the cases have the same object in mind – redress for alleged bribery by Shell and others.

Nigeria’s lawyer lays out that the defendants; Shell, Eni & EVP have racked up an “excessive” £3m in costs, compared to £850k by Nigeria. They call the defendants’ approach “heavy handed” and say its not appropriate for the defendants to claim costs for issues they dropped.

Interestingly Justice Butcher ruled against Shell’s arguments that Nigeria misled the court in its initial application. He found: “it does not appear to me that there was a failure to disclose or misrepresentation of matters which might have misled the court”

Justice Butcher says he won’t use Nigeria’s lawyer’s terms of “staggering” or “eye watering” but that “there probably has been a heavy handed approach on behalf of the defendants to resisting” the claim and that they racked up £3m in costs is “concerning” to the court.

Justice Butcher says costs overall were “decidedly high” and orders that FRN pay the same amount of Eni’s costs that Nigeria agreed with Shell. He says Obi/ EVP’s arguments were “optimistic” given Obi has been convicted in Italy so Nigeria will pay less of their costs

Nigeria argues that they should be allowed to appeal the judgement on the basis of several legal precedents. Eni and Shell disagree with Nigeria’s arguments and say Nigeria shouldn’t be allowed to appeal.

Nigeria will have to seek permission to appeal from the court of appeal as Justice Butcher says he won’t grant permission.

That’s the end of the hearing. Any intrepid journalists who’d like to report on the ruling please do get in touch and I can pass on a copy of the judgement.

Malabu Oil Deal: Nigerian government

The Nigerian government had sued Shell and ENI for $1.1 billion in 2011 over the licencing of OML 245 which the nation claims the said companies made it miss as a result of bribes they paid to Malabu oil, owned by former Minister of Petroleum Dan Etete. 

While Shell and ENI paid a signature bonus of $210 million to the federal government, they paid $1.1 billion to buy 100 percent interest in the oil block from Malabu. The entire $1.3 billion was transferred to the account of the federal government in London, UK, from where Malabu was paid its $1.1 billion. However both oil companies have denied the bribery allegations, with  Eni saying it made no profit from the deal because “Nigeria declined to grant a mining license”.


More articles

Leave a Reply


Latest article

This Is Us Star Justin Hartley Spotted Kissing Co-Star Amid Messy Divorce!

Has this little mystery been solved? Or is this just another sad turn of events from one of...

Khloé Kardashian Addresses Her Drastically ‘Different’ Faces In Photos After Going Viral!

Khloé Kardashian has had the time this week! After firing off on critics who questioned her famous family throwing a not-socially-distanced...

BBNaija Pepper Dem housemates set to storm reality tv show’s reunion party

Following the announcement of the 5th edition of the Big Brother Naija reality TV show, housemates of the 4th edition will be...

Toyin Lawani shows off new boyfriend in ‘pre-wedding photos’

Celebrity stylist, Toyin Lawani is showing off her new boyfriend on social media, in what she tagged as a pre-wedding photo shoot.

Julianne Hough Officially Splits from Husband Brooks Laich

The two confirmed the news after deciding to quarantine apart. It's over for Julianne Hough and husband of almost three years,...