Hundreds of thousands of voters cast ballots marked “uncommitted” in Democratic presidential primaries this year in opposition to President Biden’s policy toward Israel’s war in Gaza.
Now that Vice President Harris has replaced Biden at the top of the ticket, organizers behind the movement are expressing cautious optimism about their ability to engage with Harris.
Abbas Alawieh, a co-founder of the uncommitted movement, said at a news conference in recent days, “There are early indications that there is an openness to engaging with our movement that feels like a shift from how our requests were being treated previously.
“And so I’m choosing to remain hopeful that the vice president won’t miss the opportunity to unite our party.”
Layla Elabed is another co-founder of the uncommitted movement, and said Harris’ candidacy provides a window of opportunity.
“VP Harris has shown that she is a little more empathetic to our movement. She spoke of Palestinian right to self-determination. She spoke about the suffering that Palestinians are experiencing right now,” Elabed said in an interview. “And so it’s a slightly different shift in language than what we’ve seen from President Biden and his administration.”
Elabed and other leaders cited the vice president’s comments after a meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during his trip to Washington in late July, just days after Biden ended his candidacy.
Harris asserted Israel’s right to defend itself, but added, “how it does so matters.”
“The images of dead children and desperate hungry people fleeing for safety, sometimes displaced for the second, third or fourth time,” Harris said. “We cannot look away in the face of these tragedies. We cannot allow ourselves to become numb to the suffering, and I will not be silent.”
A key movement in a key state
The uncommitted movement grew out of the “Listen to Michigan” campaign ahead of that state’s February presidential primary. Its goal was to send a strong message to Biden that he needed to do more to prevent civilian deaths in Gaza. Organizers’ primary demands are for an immediate cease-fire in Gaza, and an end to U.S. weapons transfers to Israel.
Michigan has a sizable Arab American population, and in the presidential primary more than 100,000 voters cast ballots for “uncommitted,” representing about 13% of all votes cast.
Biden carried Michigan in 2020 by just 154,000 votes, and it remains a crucial swing state.
Vice President Harris, the Democratic presidential nominee, speaks during a campaign rally at Detroit Metropolitan Airport on Wednesday.
Jeff Kowalsky/AFP via Getty Images
This week, Harris met briefly with two leaders of the movement prior to a campaign rally in Michigan.
Alawieh said it was a brief encounter backstage in a receiving line. He said he told Harris that previously uncommitted voters want to support her, but need to know she’ll take a different path on Gaza.
“And I asked her, ‘Will you meet with us so that we can discuss an arms embargo?’” he recounted. “And the vice president was very quick to say, ‘I’d really like that.’ And we took the photo and I said, ‘Thank you so much.’”
He said it was not a commitment of specific policy, but to keep meeting regarding these urgent concerns.
Later, Phil Gordon, a Harris national security adviser, stressed in a post on X that, “She does not support an arms embargo on Israel.”
There were some pro-Palestinian protesters at this week’s Michigan rally, who at one point interrupted the vice president with chants of, “Kamala, Kamala, you can’t hide. We won’t vote for genocide.”
At first, Harris gave them their moment, but as the interruption persisted she cut them off, implying that Donald Trump’s election would be truly bad for their cause.
“If you want Donald Trump to win, then say that. Otherwise, I am speaking,” Harris said.
What voters are looking for from Harris
It remains to be seen if Harris’ policy regarding Gaza would be substantively different from that of the Biden administration.
Organizers of the uncommitted movement stress that a shift in language is not enough. They continue to push for an immediate cease-fire in Gaza, plus an end of U.S. weapon sales to Israel. And they’ve requested speaking time at the Democratic National Convention later this month for a doctor who has worked on the frontlines in Gaza.
Abdullah Hammoud, the mayor of Dearborn, Mich., a city where a large portion of the population is of Middle Eastern or North African descent, praised Harris’ remarks after the Netanyahu visit, but said: “What we want is more than just someone who is tough on rhetoric. We want somebody who is tough on policy. From our perspective, our values have not changed. The policy positions that we’ve been advocating for have not been altered.”
Elabad, one of the co-founders of the uncommitted movement, said she wants to see guarantees that Harris is turning a page on Biden’s policy, and said that Palestinians “cannot eat words.”
The core of the uncommitted movement is Arab Americans and younger voters. Many are still deciding what they’ll do in November.
Kole Cuderna, an 18-year-old from Holland, Mich., voted uncommitted in February. He said he likely would have voted for Biden in the general election, but reluctantly.
“With Biden I did not feel any enthusiasm,” he said. “But with Harris, it’s like, yeah, I’m enthusiastic. I’m excited about Harris. I feel like she can win.”
But 41-year-old Jennifer Schlicht’s reaction was more tempered. She said she is waiting to see if Harris produces any policy changes toward the Middle East.
“Will I vote for her? Most likely,” said Schlicht, from Ypsilanti, Mich. “But I would feel a lot better voting for her if she did follow up with those words that she spoke to Netanyahu about, and came out in favor of something that respects the right to live of the Palestinian people.”
Then there are voters like Hank Kennedy, a student teacher from Hazel Park, Mich., who said a new candidate does not change his calculus at all.
“There needs to be a policy change, not just a change at the top of the ticket,” said Kennedy, 27.
If the election were tomorrow, Kennedy says he would likely vote for the Green Party, (For their part, uncommitted organizers are not recommending voters support a third party.)
And while Kennedy also said he’s concerned about what another Trump presidency might mean for Palestinians, he said he doesn’t feel like Democrats have done enough to stop the death and destruction in Gaza.
“If we’re supposed to vote for the lesser of two evils? I mean, what’s lesser? That’s the way I look at it,” he said.
