LONDON — French Champagne producers have been left fuming over a new Russian law that they say tries to undermine their world-famous brand.
Champagne is a region in the northeast of France, but more famously is the name of the sparkling wine produced there.
Russian authorities are challenging that with a new law put forward earlier this week that requires French Champagne producers to add the words “sparkling wine” on the back of the label if they want to sell their bottles in Russia. Champagne producers are proud of their name and brand and refuse to use any reference to “sparkling wine.”
The same law allows Russian producers of sparkling wine to use “shampanskoye” — the Russian word for Champagne — on their bottles.
“We are just shocked,” Charles Goemaere, director general of the Champagne Committee, a trade association that represents independent Champagne producers and houses, told CNBC on Thursday.
The “first financial damage,” he said, is that producers “are unable to export champagne to the Russian market despite (previous) orders.” Changing labels on bottles that are ready to be shipped would be a technical and financial challenge.
The French Champagne industry asked its members to halt shipments to Russia for now, stating that the name “Champagne” is protected in over 120 countries.
In 2020 alone, Champagne producers exported 2.6 billion euros ($3.07 billion) worth of bottles globally. The top buyers were the U.K., the U.S., and Japan, according to data from the Champagne Committee.
“Russia’s new bill is of course designed to support domestic producers,” Fredrik Erixon, director at the think tank ECIPE, said via email.
A new WTO dispute
The protection of the name “Champagne” comes under what is known as “geographical indications” or GIs. This concept in international trade recognizes that certain signs, usually names, identify a particular product with its territory. In essence, the quality and reputation of the item is attributed to its geographic origin.
This is the case for sparkling wine produced in Champagne, but also Scottish whisky, Roquefort cheese and so on.
Goemaere, of the Champagne Committee, the industry wants French and European officials “to initiate discussions with the Russian authorities to find a solution.”
“We will unfailingly support our producers and French excellence,” Franck Riester, France’s trade minister, said earlier this week on Twitter.
This dispute could ultimately reach the World Trade Organization.
The new Russian law “doesn’t deny French producers in Champagne to use the Champagne label, nor does the bill deny that there is a Champagne appellation that is unique to the French region. Hence, France and the EU cannot make a straightforward case if they table a complaint at the WTO.
However, he added that France and the EU “may still win such a case since the Russians seem to err on the wrong side” of well-established geographical indicators.
In addition, Erixon said that “unless there is a bilateral solution found soon, I am sure that the EU would file a complaint. Protecting GIs is a central plank of EU trade policy and there are risks that other countries would follow Russia’s example if it would stand up.”
